
Courtyard by Marriott Edinburgh: stone frontage on Baxter’s Place.
We stayed at Courtyard by Marriott Edinburgh on November 6–7, 2026, for the Friday night of a weekend built around Scotland versus the All Blacks at Murrayfield. We wanted to spend the first evening in central Edinburgh before moving to Holiday Inn Express Edinburgh City West for Saturday night, and the Courtyard put us within an easy walk of plenty of Scottish pubs.
The booking started as a free night certificate redemption before an Amex offer changed the calculation. Once the train and match tickets were booked, a prepaid cash rate became more acceptable, and we switched. The stay then brought a balcony upgrade and a pretty decent bar for a Courtyard, although housekeeping and breakfast service each delivered an avoidable annoyance.
From a certificate to a cash booking
I initially held a cancelable reservation using a 35,000-point Marriott free night certificate (FNC) plus 23,000 points, covering a total award price of 58,000 points.
The quoted cash alternative was $353 for a nonrefundable prepaid rate. Compared with the 58,000-point award price, that was a fairly uninspiring 0.61 cents per point on the headline numbers. Still, while our trip remained uncertain, the award booking’s flexibility was useful.
Once the train and match tickets were purchased, we were ready to commit to the hotel. A UK Amex offer providing £70 back on £200 of Marriott spending made cash more attractive, so we prepaid and released the FNC and points for another stay. The actual charge was £252, and the £70 credit posted the following day, leaving a net room cost of £182.
I explore the booking decision in more detail in When Cash Beat My Marriott Certificate.
The stay earned 3423 Bonvoy points: 2282 base points and a 1141-point Platinum Elite bonus.
Arrival and the balcony upgrade
The building’s layout means the street-level entrance is on level five. Our room was one floor down on level four, the same floor as the restaurant, so we took the elevator down from reception.
We used one Nightly Upgrade Award and received a room with a balcony at the rear of the hotel. At reception, the clerk described it as their highest room category. That was a useful upgrade for our stay, giving us some private outdoor space beyond the bedroom.

The balcony had two chairs and a small table, overlooking the buildings and trees behind the hotel.
The balcony was covered, with brick side walls and a view toward older buildings and autumn trees. It was a sheltered little sitting area rather than a panoramic city-view terrace. Still, it was a nice addition to a central Edinburgh room, and we had several Nightly Upgrade Awards left to use at this late stage in the year.
The bedroom
The room combined a large bed with a wood-paneled headboard, a green armchair, and a glass desk beside the balcony doors. Opposite the bed, a wall-mounted television sat above a long shelf holding the refreshments, with an upholstered stool tucked underneath.
The layout allowed several places to sit or put things without completely filling the room with furniture.

The bedroom, with the balcony at the far end and the television and refreshment shelf opposite the bed.
There was a separate glass desk with an office chair beside the balcony doors. We did not need it for work during this weekend stay.

A glass desk and office chair beside the balcony doors.
The room also had a kettle and a capsule coffee machine, with supplies on the shelf opposite the bed.

The capsule coffee machine and accompanying supplies.
Bathroom and an empty dispenser
The bathroom had a walk-in shower, a wall-hung toilet, and a rectangular basin beneath a large illuminated mirror. Towels were stored beneath the vanity, and the shower used wall-mounted refillable toiletries.

The bathroom vanity.

The bathroom and walk-in shower.
My only room complaint was discovering, once I was in the shower, that the body wash dispenser was completely empty. I used the hand soap from the basin instead.
A bar worth staying in for
The 1802 bar and lounge was a real positive feature. Slate-blue walls, mustard seating, and several distinct seating areas made it more inviting than your typical functional lobby bar. At check-in, I was offered a choice between welcome points and a food and beverage credit worth $10. I chose the credit, and we had a drink in the bar before going out.

The 1802 bar, where we had a drink before heading out for the evening.
The seating extends into adjoining lounge spaces and onto the street-front terrace. Outside, covered tables and heat lamps make the terrace a usable extension of the bar in cooler weather.

Covered seating on the street-front terrace.
The central location also made it easy to leave the hotel and explore nearby pubs. That was the purpose of choosing this property for Friday night, and it worked well without requiring us to arrange transport for the evening.
Breakfast
Breakfast was included in our booked rate. The food was good, with a hot buffet that included haggis alongside the usual cooked breakfast options.

The hot breakfast buffet.
After being assigned a table, I left to collect coffee and food, then returned to find it had been given to another guest. It was a minor incident, but an assigned-table system should account for guests visiting the buffet.

My cooked breakfast, with bread, fruit and yogurt, and coffee.
Express checkout and a welcome-credit correction
There was a queue at checkout, so I used the express-checkout option and dropped off the key. A charge later appeared for our 1802 visit and taxes, totaling about £16.
When I later called the hotel, the clerk confirmed that the $10 Platinum food-and-beverage welcome credit I had chosen instead of points had not been applied. He said that, because of the inconvenience, the hotel would waive the whole bill rather than just deduct the $10 credit. It was a generous response to a small billing error, and a nice way to finish the stay.
Would I stay again?
Courtyard Edinburgh worked well for the central-city portion of our weekend. The location gave us easy access to the town, the balcony was a useful upgrade, and the bar offered somewhere pleasant to have a drink before going out.
The empty body wash dispenser and breakfast table mix-up were small but avoidable failures. Neither would rule out a return, although both were details the hotel should have handled correctly.
I would consider staying again at a competitive rate, particularly with another card offer. The balcony room improved this stay, while the location and public spaces would make the hotel worth considering even without that upgrade. The hotel’s willingness to waive the bar bill after the missed welcome credit also left a positive final impression.