
Our room at Courtyard Edinburgh. The booking method changed; the hotel did not.
My first reservation for Friday night in Edinburgh was a Marriott free night certificate (FNC) plus 23,000 points. By the time we arrived, I had canceled that award booking and prepaid for the same hotel instead.
The room did not change. Neither did the weekend: we were going to Scotland versus the All Blacks at Murrayfield, with Friday evening reserved for Edinburgh's pubs before moving to another hotel on Saturday. What changed was the value of flexibility, along with a credit-card offer that made paying cash more appealing than giving up an FNC and points.
The initial reservation was not a mistake. It was the right provisional choice at the time, when we were still working out whether the trip would go ahead. Once the arrangements were confirmed, the numbers deserved another look.
The first booking: an FNC and 23,000 points
Courtyard by Marriott Edinburgh was quoting $353 for our Friday night on a nonrefundable prepaid rate. The award alternative required 58,000 points, which I could cover with a 35k FNC and a 23,000-point top-up.

Courtyard Edinburgh, 6–7 November: 58,000 points or $353 per night, including taxes and fees.
On the headline numbers, 58,000 points against $353 produces a redemption rate of about 0.61 cents per point. That is below Frequent Miler's current Reasonable Redemption Value of 0.73 cents for Marriott points, which I use as my working valuation, and would not be particularly attractive if I were spending 58,000 unrestricted points.
But I wasn't. I was using an FNC with a fixed nominal ceiling, plus a smaller balance of points. Those are different assets with different constraints.
The FNC could not be cashed out and had an expiration date. Its practical value depended on finding a suitable redemption before then. The 23,000-point top-up was more flexible: those points could be used on another stay. At 0.73 cents per Marriott point, the top-up represented ~$167.90 of value.
The other benefit was cancellation flexibility, which is often useful around sporting events. While we were still deciding whether to travel, I could release the award booking without committing to the hotel's prepaid cash rate.
Knowing we had somewhere to stay while sorting out match tickets and transportation was useful, even if the headline redemption value wasn't especially compelling.
Then the trip became definite
After finding suitable train tickets from London to Edinburgh, incorporating the one-third discount from our Two Together Railcard, we eventually secured both train and match tickets.
That removed the uncertainty the award booking had been protecting against. We were now committed to Edinburgh, and the option to cancel the hotel had less value to us. The prepaid cash rate was £252 when we reconsidered the booking, approximately $333 using an exchange rate of £1 = $1.32.
At the same time, a UK Amex offer provided £70 back on £200 of Marriott spending. We had an eligible card with the offer available, so the prepaid booking became more attractive.
The £252 charge posted on October 29 as EDICY PMS EDINBURGH, followed by a £70 credit on October 30 from COURTYARD MARRIOTT EDINBURGH. That left a net room cost of £182, approximately $240.

£252 charged on 29 October; £70 credited on 30 October. Net room cost: £182.
The offer did not eliminate the cash expenditure. We still paid for the room, accepted nonrefundable terms and used a limited-time benefit that might otherwise have been available for another Marriott transaction.
For this comparison, I am assuming the Amex offer would otherwise have gone unused. If I had another qualifying Marriott purchase planned, some or all of the £70 rebate would need to be attributed to that alternative instead. It was the combination of a confirmed trip and the available rebate that made switching from the award worthwhile.
The final calculation
The original $353 cash rate against 58,000 points produced a headline redemption value of 0.61 cents per point. That was already below my normal Marriott valuation, although the FNC made the comparison less straightforward.
After the Amex rebate, the cash alternative fell to approximately $240. Dividing that by the 58,000 points of nominal award value gives just 0.41 cents per point.
That is a useful headline figure, but it still treats the FNC as though it were equivalent to unrestricted Marriott points. The more interesting comparison was the incremental cost of preserving the FNC.
The 23,000-point top-up was worth ~$167.90 at my working valuation. Paying $240 instead of redeeming the award therefore meant spending an additional ~$72.10 to retain the 35K certificate, before considering the points earned on the paid stay.
Courtyard subsequently credited 3423 Marriott points for our stay, consisting of 2282 base points and 1141 Platinum Elite bonus points. At 0.73 cents per point, those earnings were worth ~$24.99. Including those points reduced the incremental cost of retaining the FNC to ~$47.11.
Component | Value |
|---|---|
Net prepaid cash cost after Amex | $240 |
Value of 23,000 points retained | ($167.90) |
Value of 3423 points earned | ($24.99) |
Incremental cost of preserving 35K FNC | ~$47 |
This calculation excludes incremental credit-card rewards and assumes the Amex offer had no alternative use. It also assumes the paid-stay points were incremental to what I would have earned on the award booking.
The question was therefore not whether I preferred spending $240 or 58,000 unrestricted points. It was whether paying ~$47 to preserve a 35K certificate was worthwhile.
That depended on the likelihood of using the certificate effectively before expiration. A 35K FNC is not worth $255.50 merely because that is the value of 35,000 points at 0.73 cents each. It can be worth less, particularly if the expiration date is approaching or suitable redemption opportunities are scarce.
If I expected to use the certificate for another stay where it would save more than $47, retaining it was the better financial decision. With nine months remaining before expiration, I was comfortable taking that option.
One unexpected adjustment
There was a small post-stay complication that was unrelated to the original booking decision.
A separate charge of approximately £16 appeared for our visit to the hotel's 1802 bar and associated taxes. There had been a queue at checkout, so I used express checkout and dropped off the key rather than reviewing the bill at reception. When I called the hotel on November 16, the clerk confirmed that the $10 Platinum food-and-beverage welcome credit I had selected instead of points had not been applied.
He offered to waive the entire bar bill rather than just correct the missing credit. That was a welcome outcome, although not one I would include in the original cash-versus-award calculation. It was an unexpected service recovery, not a saving I could have anticipated when making the reservation.
The stay at Courtyard Edinburgh
The hotel gave us a balcony room after I applied a Nightly Upgrade Award. We used the 1802 bar before going out, and the central location suited our Friday evening.
There were a couple of annoyances, including an empty body-wash dispenser and confused table management at breakfast. Those are covered in the separate Courtyard Edinburgh review, along with the room, facilities and overall experience.

The balcony room we stayed in after applying a Nightly Upgrade Award.
The payment decision and the hotel experience were separate questions. We stayed at the property we had originally selected, enjoyed the same location and received the same accommodation we would have expected under the award booking.
For next time
I would again hold a cancelable award while an event weekend remained uncertain, provided the cancellation terms allowed it and the certificate was not about to expire unused. That flexibility gave us time to secure the train and rugby tickets without exposing ourselves to a nonrefundable hotel charge.
Once the trip became definite, I would reprice the cash alternative, check available card offers and compare the cost of retaining the certificate and points against the net cash expenditure. I would also include the points expected from a paid stay, while avoiding the temptation to count credits that could have been used elsewhere as entirely incremental savings.
If the certificate were close to expiration, or I had no realistic alternative use for it, the award might still be preferable. A refundable cash rate at a modest premium could also be worth considering if travel plans remained uncertain.
In Edinburgh, the revised booking allowed me to retain the 35K certificate and 23,000 points, earn another 3423 Marriott points and use a £70 Amex offer that otherwise might have expired unused.
On my valuations, the incremental cost of keeping the certificate was ~$47. That is the number I would use when deciding whether the switch was worthwhile, not the original 0.61 cents per point.