Fira and the caldera, explored between our three resort stays.
We spent three nights in Santorini, moving from Vedema in Megalochori to Katikies Garden in Fira and then Magma. Each stay used American Express Fine Hotels + Resorts and a separate $300 Platinum hotel credit. Around the hotels, we walked through village lanes, spent an evening watching the light change over the caldera and reached Oia long after its famous sunset.
This Collection brings together twelve articles covering the booking decisions, the three hotel stays, the places we explored and the loyalty results. The final comparison draws those experiences together, including the questions on which my wife and I disagreed.
If You Read Only One Piece
The full reflection on the three resorts. We compare the room upgrades and their observed price premiums, breakfasts, location and the experience of moving every night. Vedema delivered the most impressive upgrade, Katikies Garden had the strongest breakfast verdict and our preferences diverged when we considered longer stays and caldera rooms.
Planning the Trip
The original hotel plan explains why we booked three separate one-night stays at broadly similar prices. It sets out how the Platinum credits and FHR benefits shaped the shortlist and why we wanted to try several of Santorini's less expensive FHR options.
The flight booking needed to protect our limited time on the island. We compared cash and award options, chose direct flights into Santorini and used the later return to keep another morning and lunch at Magma. Separate reservations also let us buy one checked bag between us and use two Aspire airline credits.
Three Resorts, Three Settings
Our first night was at Vedema, built into the village of Megalochori. An unexpected upgrade from a Dorian Suite to the Olympian Villa gave us a private pool, a separate living area and an open vineyard outlook.
Katikies Garden combined a former monastery setting with the convenience of walking into Fira. We stayed in a Senior Jetted Tub Suite, had breakfast in the courtyard and chose dinner overlooking the caldera instead of Selene's tasting menu.
Magma was our final stop, with a private-pool room upgrade, a shared pool and restaurant terrace, and a scheduled shuttle into Fira. Our stay included a hurried Champagne breakfast, an evening trip to Oia and a relaxed final lunch before the airport transfer.
While We Were There
Vedema put us within Megalochori itself. Evening and morning walks took us through quiet lanes, small courtyards and church squares, with the village's wine-making history visible in the surrounding vineyards and restored cellars.
We walked down into Fira from Katikies Garden, explored its passages and galleries, then settled at Lithos for around three hours of drinks, dinner and sunset. The climb back after dark revealed a different view of the town's staircases and hillside terraces.
We reached Oia after sunset and stayed beyond midnight. The evening took us past illuminated churches and cliffside terraces before an unexpected stop at Andronis, where a bartender streamed the World Cup final on his phone for us.
The Loyalty Results
The three hotel bookings also produced separate tests of how FHR reservations interact with hotel loyalty programmes. These articles follow the credits, points and recognition through to the results, including the posting work needed after the stays.
At Vedema, we combined a prepaid FHR booking with Marriott Platinum benefits, Bonvoy recognition and points earned on the stay.
Katikies Garden tested whether a third-party FHR booking would also earn Leaders Club points. Ours needed a claim before they were credited manually.
At Magma, we checked what posted to World of Hyatt from the FHR stay and how the hotel and credit-card benefits fitted together.
A Week in Melbourne · AN EXPATVISTA COLLECTION
Amsterdam in August · AN EXPATVISTA COLLECTION
Prague in January · AN EXPATVISTA COLLECTION


