Part of Three Nights in Santorini · AN EXPATVISTA COLLECTION
We spent three nights in Santorini and stayed at three different resorts: Vedema, Katikies Garden and Magma. Each was booked through American Express Fine Hotels + Resorts at a broadly similar price, using a separate $300 Platinum hotel credit. The booking logic is in Why I Booked Three Santorini Resorts. This is the reflection after staying at them, including the parts where my wife and I reached different conclusions.
The original question was whether the less expensive FHR options could deliver a satisfying Santorini trip without paying for a room perched above the caldera. They did, although that did not settle every question. The biggest upgrade was not at the hotel with the best location, the place I could most easily imagine spending longer was not the one I most wanted to revisit, and we disagreed about whether a caldera room was still worth trying.
Vedema's Olympian Villa gave us the most memorable accommodation upgrade of the three stays.
Similar bills, different starting points
Our order was Vedema, Katikies Garden, then Magma. That took us from the village setting of Megalochori to Fira, followed by a final night with a more conventional poolside resort rhythm. We liked the sequence and would use the same order again.
One-night stay | Room booked | Room received | Room cost including recorded local charge | After $300 Platinum hotel credit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Vedema | Dorian Suite | Olympian Villa | $495.22 | $195.22 |
Katikies Garden | Junior Suite | Senior Jetted Tub Suite | $536.21 | $236.21 |
Magma | King Room | King Sea View Room with Private Pool | $496.08 | $196.08 |
Those figures include the $17.08 local charge recorded for each resort in my trip spreadsheet. For example at Vedema, this reconciles the $478.14 prepaid room charge with the $495.22 total I had used in the planning article. Across the three nights, the room costs came to $1527.51, or $627.51 after the three $300 credits. Meals beyond the included benefits, transfers and other incidentals sit outside that total.
Breakfast for two came with every stay, alongside property credits of $100 at Vedema, $100 at Katikies Garden and $150 at Magma. Those benefits helped shape what we did at each property. We used the property credits on meals onsite, so they reduced what we paid for dining. The room-cost table above shows the cost after the Platinum credits, with the dining benefits accounted for separately. The retail price of the upgrades is a different story. I would have been unlikely to pay for the upgrades from the starting rooms myself had they not been granted.
Vedema's Dorian Suite already has a living area, and Katikies Garden's Junior Suite is already a generous room. Magma's standard King Room is closer to what its name suggests. Interestingly, similar booking prices did not mean we began with equivalent accommodation, even before anyone offered an upgrade.
What the upgrades were worth
I had saved room-rate screenshots during the trip, which gave us a way to put some numbers around the upgrades. They are useful evidence of how the categories were priced, but the screenshots do not show the searched stay dates. These are historical category comparisons, not proof that we could have booked the same night on identical terms at those prices.
Property | Screenshot comparison | Observed category premium |
|---|---|---|
Vedema | Dorian Suite $368 → Olympian Villa $1070 | $702, or about 191% |
Katikies Garden | Junior Suite → Senior Jetted Tub Suite | About 22%; approximately $75 prepaid or $92 flexible at the illustrative conversion below |
Magma | King Sea View $484 → King Sea View with Private Pool $699 | $215, or about 44%, for the pool on a same-view comparison |
The Katikies screenshots were in euros: €290 versus €355 prepaid, or €360 versus €440 on flexible rates. The dollar premiums above use an illustrative $1.15 per euro to make the scale easier to compare. Magma needs a separate qualification: the screenshot base was a Sea View King, while our booking was a standard King. The $215 isolates the pool premium within the sea-view category, not the full premium from our booked room to the one received.
Vedema was the clear standout on both the snapshot price gap and my reaction to the accommodation. Receiving the Olympian Villa felt like being given a little house, with space inside and a large private pool outside. The open outlook across the vineyards added to that feeling. It was unexpected, and it changed the experience more than either of the other upgrades.
The villa's separate living space was part of the upgrade, alongside the private pool and terrace.
The interiors were comfortable rather than cutting-edge, but that was not a problem for us. With more time, we could have spent much longer outside beside the pool. My wife particularly liked the size of the pool and outdoor space, without calling it her favourite room overall.
Katikies Garden was a different case. Our room was the Senior Jetted Tub Suite, not the sea-view version. The smaller category premium initially surprised me, but it makes more sense once you recognise how good the starting suite already was. We had a spacious, private room and outdoor areas; the upgrade did not transform a basic bedroom into a villa.
Katikies Garden started from a strong suite offering, so its smaller upgrade premium needs that context.
The jetted tub was the obvious extra, but it was not hot and we did not get much use from it. We enjoyed wine on the lower private terrace, which was more useful for our stay. A feature can have a published price premium without contributing much to the way we spend a night, and this was a good example.
The rooftop tub added an outdoor feature, but it was not warm enough to become a highlight for us.
Magma's private pool was a welcome addition to a room that otherwise felt the most hotel-like of the three. It was a pleasant room, but less distinctive than the accommodation at Vedema or Katikies Garden. The upgrade gave us somewhere private to swim and sit outside, even though the shared pool terrace was also a reason to spend time at the property.
Magma's room upgrade added a private pool to a more conventional hotel room.
All three upgrades improved the stays, but I would not build a repeat booking around receiving them again. They were subject to availability, and recognition through hotel loyalty programmes also formed part of these visits. The strongest outcome was Vedema; the least dependence on an upgrade was Katikies Garden. I would still consider all three for a one-night stay in the categories we originally booked.
Breakfast: Katikies takes the lead
My wife was clearest on this question: Katikies Garden had the best breakfast food. She liked the extensive à la carte choice and thought it stood above Vedema. I enjoyed both, so my own ranking was less emphatic, but Katikies also had the setting that most strongly made breakfast feel like an occasion.
We were seated in the former monastery courtyard used by the hotel's main dining operation. You felt you were somewhere special before the food arrived. Service was a little slow, without an obvious reason, but it was fine and did not spoil the experience. The combination of the courtyard and the breakfast itself makes it the easiest overall recommendation of the three.
Katikies Garden combined our strongest breakfast food verdict with the monastery courtyard setting.
Vedema's breakfast was relaxed and poolside, with an à la carte approach and encouragement to order widely. We enjoyed it, even if the Kayianas egg dish was not a favourite. The cats were a quirky part of the surroundings and did not get in the way. For me, it was a pleasant breakfast in an interesting setting; my wife was more reserved about the food than I was.
Vedema's poolside breakfast was a relaxed start to the day.
Magma is harder to judge fairly because we gave it only about 15 minutes before catching the Fira shuttle. I found the food offering more like a conventional hotel buffet than the other two breakfasts. My wife thought the scale and presentation of the buffet were impressive, but agreed that we had not spent enough time eating to assess the taste properly.
It also included Champagne. That didn’t seem to be a one-off: Hyatt's own resort information advertises a Champagne buffet breakfast. It added something to the occasion, even though our rushed visit leaves Magma with the least complete breakfast assessment.
Magma's buffet impressed my wife with its scale, but our short visit limited the food comparison.
Location, dining and time at the hotel
Katikies Garden's position in Fira was its most useful everyday advantage. We could come and go without organising transport, then return to a setting that felt separate from the busy town. That combination appealed especially to my wife. For three or four days, or even a week, it was her choice because she likes being able to walk out and do things.
There is also an unfinished dining experience there. We did not eat Selene's tasting menu: we chose a caldera sunset evening at Lithos instead, and used our hotel credit at lunch. I would happily consider another one-night stay at Katikies Garden to try Selene, and my wife also wanted to return for the dinner we skipped.
Vedema gave us a different sort of stay, with Megalochori nearby, wine tasting and the villa's open outlook. It was an interesting place to spend a night, and the accommodation encouraged us to imagine spending more time outside. Once we had done the wine experience and explored the immediate setting, however, I did not feel a strong need to pay for a week there. My wife was also content to have tried it without feeling drawn to repeat it, even if the villa were guaranteed.
Magma partly offsets its position outside Fira with a complimentary scheduled shuttle. We used the 10am departure and returned at 12:30pm, so the town was accessible without arranging a separate transfer. The resort itself advertises its schedule of shuttle services to Fira and the beach. That narrows Katikies Garden's transport advantage, although a timetable is still different from walking out whenever you feel like it.
Magma's shared pool and restaurant terrace made it easy to imagine spending an unhurried day at the hotel.
For me, Magma was the easiest to picture as a longer, leisurely stay. The shared pool, restaurant and bar worked together as somewhere to sit, eat and hang around, with the shuttle available when we wanted to go into town. The room was less distinctive, but I could comfortably spend a quiet day around the property.
It was a tentative preference, not a strong recommendation to spend a week there. Two or three nights is normally enough for me at this sort of hotel, and having tried Magma's food and surroundings, I do not feel much pull to actually return for another single night. Vedema and Katikies Garden were more interesting experiences to me; Magma had the more obvious rhythm for someone wanting to relax by the pool over several days.
Dining was good across the trip, including the more relaxed meals at the hotels. Service was also excellent throughout. There were individual moments, including a pool-cleaning visit at Vedema that interrupted my sense of privacy, but my wife just saw that as staff looking after our pool. Neither of us found a persuasive service winner, and she described the service across all three as impeccable.
Did moving every day waste the trip?
For us, it did not. Packing, checking out and transferring did not feel as though they took away noticeable holiday time. We are used to moving around, and trying the different hotels was part of this trip's appeal. My wife agreed, including on the order.
There was a transport cost. The airport-to-Vedema transfer and the two hotel-to-hotel transfers were each €40. Only the latter two were additional moves between resorts; the airport transfer was an arrival cost we would have faced in some form anyway. That distinction is useful when assessing the economics of changing hotels.
The timing also worked. Vedema granted our requested 2pm checkout. At the end of the trip, a 5:25pm flight let us spend time at Magma over lunch and by the pool before our 2pm airport transfer. We had the FHR room benefit through 4pm but did not use the final two hours. Late checkout helped the shape of the trip without every available hour needing to be consumed.
The caldera question remains personal
None of these stays gave us the classic cliff-edge room and private pool looking directly down over the caldera. I felt we experienced that part of Santorini by visiting Fira and Oia, stopping for drinks and spending around three hours over dinner, wine and sunset at Lithos in Fira. Enjoying the view did not require it to be the view from our bedroom.
That was enough for me. I would not be keen to pay something like twice as much for a room to spend the day looking at the same scenery, and I do not feel that such a stay is missing from my own experience. Prices vary, of course; that was the sort of premium I had in mind.
My wife disagreed. She would still like a cliff-facing room after seeing the setting at an Andronis property in Oia, ideally for a weekend. A view over dinner did not tick the same box for her as waking up there and spending time in the room.
What we would book next
Question | Our conclusion |
|---|---|
Most impressive upgrade? | Vedema's Olympian Villa, especially the private pool and outdoor space. |
Best breakfast? | Katikies Garden, clearly for my wife; I also enjoyed Vedema. Magma was too rushed for a complete food assessment. |
Best for walking in and out of town? | Katikies Garden in Fira. |
Longer stay? | My wife: Katikies Garden. Me: tentatively Magma for poolside downtime, although I would normally stop at two or three nights. |
Book the original rooms without upgrades? | Yes, for a one-night stay. Katikies Garden was the clearest example of an already attractive base category. |
Strongest reason to return? | Katikies Garden to try Selene. Otherwise, trying somewhere new has more appeal than repeating a completed experience. |
If we go back, I would probably start by looking at NOŪS, the fourth of the less expensive FHR options on our original shortlist. We have not stayed there, so that is curiosity rather than a recommendation. Another one-night visit to Katikies Garden with dinner at Selene would also have a purpose beyond repeating a hotel we already know.
The three-night experiment worked because we enjoyed the movement and wanted different experiences. It produced a striking villa upgrade, a memorable town-centre monastery stay and a more relaxed final pool day for broadly similar room costs. I would repeat the approach, while my wife's wish for a caldera weekend is a reminder that even two people on the same trip can leave with different ideas about what to do next.
The rest of the Santorini series
The full hotel reviews cover Vedema, Katikies Garden and Magma. Our time outside the hotels is in Megalochori, Fira and Oia, with the travel decision in Why I Paid Cash for Santorini Flights.
For the loyalty results behind the stays, see the separate articles on FHR and Marriott Bonvoy, FHR and Leaders Club and FHR and World of Hyatt. They explain the earning and posting details without treating points, hotel credits and upgrade prices as interchangeable forms of cash savings.