On October 16, I published Why I Booked a Hilton Room I Didn't Need.
The idea was to book one night at the Las Vegas Hilton at Resorts World, despite already having four complimentary nights at the Cosmopolitan. We were going to be in Las Vegas and eating out anyway. Could we use that spending to recover approximately $354 in expiring Hilton Aspire resort credits and trigger two targeted Amex Offers worth a combined 35,000 Hilton Honors points?
There were two reasons I liked the proposition. First, we'd recover credits we might otherwise struggle to use before they expired. Second, the additional cash expenditure made sense. Our forecast called for roughly $705 in dining and $179 worth of Hilton Honors points. After allocating the existing $354 in credits against part of the dining, our remaining $460 would buy approximately $351 more in meals and drinks, plus the points. That's $529 in things we'd happily pay for anyway, in exchange for $460 cash. I'd take that trade all day. The question was whether the hotel, restaurant and credit-card arrangements would allow us to execute it as planned.
We now have the final folio, the credit-card activity and the Hilton points results.

The Hilton room we booked despite already having accommodation at the Cosmopolitan.
First, could we get the room charges onto the right cards?
The original booking totaled $214.40, comprising a $134.10 room rate, $55 resort fee and $25.30 in taxes. We had prepaid $152.04 on Aspire 2, which had $127.90 in resort credit remaining. That credit had already posted before we arrived.
The outstanding $55 resort fee, plus $7.36 in tax, presented a small uncertainty. We'd been told it could be paid using another card at check-in, and hoped to put it on Aspire 3, which had approximately $27 of resort credit left. But it wasn't clear whether the hotel would collect the fee immediately or leave it on the folio until checkout.
In the end, it stayed on the folio. That was useful because we could allocate the outstanding balance once we knew how much restaurant spending had been charged to the room. There was some initial confusion over card authorizations and which cards had already been charged. The important distinction was between a temporary authorization and a settled payment. By checkout, it was clear that the remaining charges could be divided among the cards we selected.
We asked the front desk to put exactly $400 on Aspire 1 and $200 on Aspire 4, the amounts needed to trigger our two targeted Amex Offers. The staff were happy to accommodate the request. The remaining $46.64 went onto Aspire 3. Here's how the final allocation compared with the original plan:
Card | Planned charge | Actual charge |
|---|---|---|
Aspire 1 | $400.00 | $400.00 |
Aspire 2 | $159.40 | $152.04 prepaid |
Aspire 3 | $55.00 | $46.64 |
Aspire 4 | $200.00 | $200.00 |
Total | $814.40 | $798.68 |
The final folio showed $798.68 in charges. After the $152.04 advance payment, $646.64 remained to be settled at checkout, divided into the three payments of $400, $200 and $46.64.
That payment flexibility was essential. Had the hotel automatically collected the balance on a single card, we might have recovered the resort credits but missed one of the Amex Offer thresholds. Across the three cards with unused resort credits, we recovered $200 on Aspire 1, $127.90 on Aspire 2 and $27.06 on Aspire 3. We'd slightly underestimated the last balance, which was $27.06 rather than $26.10.
Total resort credits recovered: $354.96, against our original estimate of $354.
Both targeted Amex Offers also triggered, delivering the expected 15,000 and 20,000 Hilton Honors points.
The restaurant plan changed once we arrived
Our original article allowed $200 for Thursday lunch, $350 for dinner and $150 for Friday brunch. These were estimates rather than spending targets, but we wanted to establish that the amount of dining required to make the exercise work was realistic.
Once we arrived, two things changed our plans. First, we were hungry and ended up having a good-sized Mexican lunch at Viva! By the time we'd finished, the prospect of a $350 dinner was less appealing. Second, the hotel provided two different lists of restaurants where our dining benefits could be used. That influenced where we went for drinks and brunch.

Lunch at Viva! came to $250.94, against our original $200 estimate.

Shared dishes and cocktails at Viva!
Two dining credits, two sets of rules
Our Make a Night of It room package included a $75 food-and-beverage credit. According to the hotel's welcome letter, it could be used at five outlets:
Famous Foods
Genting Palace
Golden Monkey Tiki Lounge
Red Tail
Junior's
The letter also explained that the credit would be applied during the stay, before checkout, and that gratuities were excluded. Our Hilton Diamond benefit provided another $30 in food-and-beverage credit, but the participating restaurants were different: Junior's, Sun's Out Buns Out and Dawg House Saloon.
Junior's was the only restaurant on both lists. That made it a natural choice for Friday brunch. We could use whatever remained of the $75 package allowance while also receiving the $30 Diamond benefit. The hotel confirmed that the Diamond benefit would be deducted at source, although we weren't given a separate itemized statement showing precisely how the $30 was allocated.
What we ended up spending
Several hours after lunch at Viva!, we visited Golden Monkey Tiki Lounge for pre-dinner drinks. That was an opportunity to use part of the $75 package allowance without ordering food we didn't need.

At Golden Monkey, the package allowance covered $49.85 of our $60.85 bill. The remaining $11 was gratuities.
We went to FUHU for dinner. After our lunch at Viva!, we were less hungry than we'd expected, and dinner came to $200.27 including gratuities, well below our original $350 estimate.

FUHU at Resorts World, where we went for dinner.

Inside FUHU, with blossom decorations above the bar and dining area.
We finished with brunch and coffees at Junior’s the following morning.
Occasion | Original estimate | Actual spending |
|---|---|---|
Thursday lunch, Viva! | $200.00 | $250.94 |
Pre-dinner drinks, Golden Monkey | — | $60.85 |
Thursday dinner, FUHU | $350.00 | $200.27 |
Friday brunch and coffees, Junior's | $150.00 | $177.22 |
Total | $700.00 | $689.28 |
These totals include gratuities and are before the $75 package credit and $30 Diamond benefit. At Golden Monkey, $49.85 of the total was covered by the package allowance, while $11 in gratuities passed through to the main folio. At FUHU, the bill comprised $169.07 in food, beverages and taxes, plus $31.20 in gratuities.

Dinner at FUHU totaled $200.27 including gratuities, against our $350 estimate.
The Junior's total included our earlier coffee purchases as well as brunch, with some charges covered by the hotel dining benefits before they reached the main folio.

Bloody Marys at Junior’s, the only outlet on both of the hotel’s dining-benefit lists.
Our meal estimates were back-of-the-envelope figures to check whether roughly $700 in dining was realistic. Actual spending came to $689.28, close to what we’d anticipated, although the mix of meals and drinks changed. We didn't have to stretch our dining to reach the necessary credit-card thresholds. We ate where we wanted, adjusted the meals to our appetites and still generated sufficient hotel charges to execute the plan.
The $75 credit worked, but the folio didn't tell the whole story
This was the least intuitive part of the exercise. When we examined the running hotel folio, not every restaurant purchase appeared. Golden Monkey's gratuities were there, but the drinks covered by the package credit were missing.
Initially, that made the restaurant spending difficult to reconcile. The explanation was that eligible purchases had already been absorbed by the package allowance before the remaining charges reached the folio. The hotel supplied a separate accounting report showing how the $75 had been consumed:
Outlet and charge | Package credit applied |
|---|---|
Golden Monkey, first eligible charge | $29.26 |
Golden Monkey, second eligible charge | $20.59 |
Junior's, first coffee charge | $11.92 |
Junior's, second coffee charge | $5.96 |
Junior's, breakfast allocation | $7.27 |
Total | $75.00 |
So the full package credit was used, with $49.85 applied at Golden Monkey and the remaining $25.15 at Junior's. The lesson here is that a hotel's final folio may not show all the restaurant spending associated with a stay. If a package allowance is deducted before charges reach the room account, a separate report may be needed to establish what was consumed.
That distinction also affects the credit-card strategy. Spending absorbed by the package allowance doesn't create an additional settled card charge, so it cannot help satisfy an Amex Offer spending threshold.
What happened to the $30 Diamond benefit?
The Diamond benefit was harder to trace. The $75 package accounting clearly excluded gratuities, which passed through to the main folio. The hotel told us that the Diamond benefit had been deducted at source, but we didn't receive a comparable allocation report.
The accounting did include a $27.50 Junior's food-comp entry. Two earlier coffee gratuities of $1 and $1.50 bring that amount to exactly $30. That suggests the Diamond allowance may have absorbed those charges, although we cannot confirm the precise allocation from the records supplied. For our purposes, the important result was that both dining benefits were applied, and the hotel's final payment balance was consistent with the charges we needed to settle. But the difference in reporting between the package and Diamond benefits was interesting.
The points were better than expected
Our original projection was 51,084 Hilton Honors points. That included 35,000 from the two targeted Amex Offers, 11,402 from Aspire card spending at 14x, and 4682 from the hotel stay.
The two Amex Offers performed as planned. The credit-card earning was a little lower because the total charges were slightly lower. Our biggest discrepancy came from the Hilton stay itself.
The account showed 2535 base points and another 2535 from the Diamond 100% elite bonus. We also received 1000 Diamond MyWay welcome points, 3000 from the 2026 More Points to Play promotion and 1000 from Stay More Earn More 2026. Those five entries totaled 10,070 points for the stay, more than twice the 4682 we'd projected.
The two promotional awards appeared as separate entries in the Hilton Honors account, so this wasn't a case of mistakenly counting the same promotion twice. The overall comparison was:
Points source | Original projection | Actual posted |
|---|---|---|
Targeted Amex Offers | 35,000 | 35,000 |
Aspire card spending at 14x | 11,402 | 11,186 |
Hilton stay, Diamond and promotions | 4,682 | 10,070 |
Total | 51,084 | 56,256 |
We ended up with 5172 more Hilton points than projected, despite spending less. At our 0.35 cents-per-point valuation, 56,256 points are worth approximately $196.90, compared with $178.79 in the original model. That additional points earning was enough to marginally improve the eventual economics of the exercise.
Was it worth it?
The original plan anticipated total hotel charges of $814.40, funded by $354 in existing Aspire resort credits and $460.40 in new cash. The final charges were $798.68. We recovered $354.96 in resort credits, leaving $443.72 in new cash expenditure. Here's the complete comparison, using the same valuation assumptions as the original article:
Original forecast | Actual | |
|---|---|---|
Total hotel charges | $814.40 | $798.68 |
Aspire resort credits recovered | $354.00 | $354.96 |
New cash expenditure | $460.40 | $443.72 |
Restaurant consumption | $705.00 | $689.28 |
Hilton points earned | 51,084 | 56,256 |
Points value at 0.35 cpp | $178.79 | $196.90 |
Dining plus points value | $883.79 | $886.18 |
Value received less total charges | +$69.39 | +$87.50 |
Using the same allocation as we’d planned, the $354.96 in Aspire credits covered part of our $689.28 dining bill. Our $443.72 cash outlay then bought the remaining $334.32 in dining plus $196.90 in points value. The original $460-for-$529 proposition had become $443.72 for $531.22. We finished $18.11 ahead of plan on that measure. Dining spending and total hotel charges fell by the same amount, so the improvement came from the additional points.
I’ve valued the dining at what we paid and the points at 0.35 cents each. For us, that was an attractive exchange: we used expiring credits and directed dining we already wanted through the hotel folio. The room made that possible.
What we now know about how it works
The stay answered several practical questions we’d had when booking.
The resort fee remained payable at checkout. The $55 fee and $7.36 tax stayed on the folio, giving us flexibility over which card ultimately paid them.
The front desk split the balance as requested. Payments of $400, $200 and $46.64 let us meet both Amex Offer thresholds and use the remaining resort credit on a third card. The initial card authorizations didn’t prevent that allocation.
Restaurant spending settled through the hotel qualified for Aspire resort credits. Our credits posted successfully against the hotel payments, confirming that this approach worked for our stay at Resorts World.
The final folio didn’t show all our dining spending. We needed a separate hotel accounting report to trace the full $75 package allowance, because covered purchases were omitted from the room charges.
Both dining benefits worked at Junior’s. We used the remaining package allowance alongside the $30 Diamond benefit during our brunch visit. The hotel confirmed the Diamond deduction, although its precise allocation remained unclear.
The stay earned more points than we’d projected. The Hilton account recorded base points, the Diamond bonus, MyWay welcome points and two separate promotional awards. Together with the card spending and targeted offers, we earned 56,256 points.
How'd that work out?
The result was better than we'd projected. We recovered $354.96 in Aspire resort credits, triggered both Amex Offers, used the $75 package credit and $30 Diamond benefit, and earned 56,256 Hilton Honors points.
Our cash outlay came to $443.72, against the $460 we'd anticipated. The points were worth approximately $197 at our chosen valuation, compared with the $179 we'd expected. The trade we liked before arriving in Las Vegas had turned out a little better than planned.
Would I do it again? Absolutely, under similar circumstances. We'd need unused resort credits, worthwhile targeted offers and restaurants where we genuinely wanted to eat. Without those ingredients, booking an unnecessary hotel room would be much harder to justify.